The tolerated gender
Finally, this leaves us to gender discrimination, which is, at least lately, more of a positive one. If, many years ago, transgender model April Ashley ( the first person in UK to have a sex-change operation) was being photographed by David Bailey for Vogue, but, at the same time, witnessing her film and fashion career fall apart because of the disclosure of her sexual identity (Sunday People, 1961), things have now changed.
Andrej Pejic has already become a name in the fashion industry, partly due to his extraordinary physical features, but also because of the ambiguity that surrounds his sexual identity. Designers, headed by Jean Paul Gaultier, have decided to use him in women's fashion shows, and magazines such as Vogue Paris or Vogue Italia have promoted him in their pages, in photographs taken by Mert & Marcus or Steven Meisel. Moreover, Pejic is one of the faces of Marc by Marc Jacobs and has declared that he finds the idea of presenting both menswear and womenswear wonderful, even though he prefers women's glam clothes. The model, who has started experimenting on his look at the age of 14, is highly appreciated by designers, and Clare Coulson from Harper's Bazaar claims that this is only due to his beauty : Andrej is the perfect coat-hanger. And clothes always look better on a taller, thinner person. Harriet Quick from Vogue states that Andrej also reflects the present times and our culture. He makes people open their eyes and ask themselves questions on how one presents his own image.
The same thing is happening with transgender model Leat T, face of Givenchy and of the latest covers of Love magazine. Lea has been the muse of designer Riccardo Tisci since she was 17 and has been working with him as a sample model, and when last year he decided to include her in the campaign of the brand he used to design for, a part of the contract stipulated that the model will be able to speak freely about his transgender status. Soon after the photographs came out, Lea T was talking in an interview for New York Times about the fact that, being trans-sexual, she cannot imagine having a bright future. It's a little message, the fact that transgenders can do the same things that boys and girls do. Maybe a trans-sexual will set up a magazine and believe that he/she can be whatever he/she wants to be. This is why I did the Givenchy campaign. However, Katie Grand, chief-editor of Love magazine, spoke differently in last issue's editorial about the decision to feature Lea on the cover : We were more preoccupied by fashion than we were by biology when we decided to do this issue. Some of the models are transgender, but we included them because they are beautiful. What people do with what's inside their pants can be interesting, but less interesting, we believe, than the way they wear the pants. It's about fashion, not bodies, and as Lionel Vermeil noticed, clothes don't have a gender. Lea T, however, has actually been talking about sexes in the interview she gave to Isaac Lock : Everything is scandalous when you are trans-sexual. If a trans-sexual poses nude, it's a scandal. If he/she gets a job, it's a scandal. It's difficult to find opportunities. I wasn;t born a woman, so I can wish to be a woman. You have to be true to yourself about some things. If God came to ma and asked me what I wanted to be, I would say a woman. But I'm not a woman. I'm a trans-sexual. You have to be proud of this. If you aren't telling this to people, you are, in fact, saying that there is something wrong with it. And Riccardo Tisci mentioned in the pages of the same magazine that his choice of featuring Lea T in that issue is far from being heroic. This is not the free world that we picture. I tested this 4 years ago, when I opened a show with 8 black girls. I made Lea catwalk in a show many years ago, and people were looking at her as if she came from a different planet. Of course, some of the feedback was positive and that;s great, but many people still aren't OK with this, and I'm surprised - also because transgenders like beauty, fashion as well. Of course, some of them have money because they prostitute, but they are people who buy Givenchy, Louis Vuitton, Dolce&Gabbana or Chanel. Why should we hide from this? Tisci's act, however, says a lot of things, and not all of them are good,no matter how worthwhile his intentions may be. The same goes with Marc Jacobs' travesty on the cover of Industrie magazine, or James Franco's in Candy.
As long as window display mannequins are starting to lack faces, Afro-American or Asian ones, or over-sized ones don't sell and aren't used, we are still talking discrimination. The same goes when brands such as American Apparel, Abercrombie & Fitch or even Prada choose their employees based on their looks. Rina Bovrisse's trial, ex-employee of Prada in Japan, who has been fired and harassed because she wasn't following the Prada Look, has brought together more employees of the company who had filed similar complaints, and this does not help the brand's image. Moreover, she claims that fashion discriminates, still. And it's not just the negative discrimination, but the positive, too. Because, as we know, the latter comes from an excess, from fixing a mistake. And the success of a Lea T is partly due to the craving for any kind of publicity that makes clothes or magazines sell, but because of this type of tolerance, as well, which, most often, only does good to the prides of those who tolerate. It's not a virtue to tolerate, because this is what gives you the impression that you are superior and, therefore, in a condition to tolerate. Likewise, to those tolerated or positively discriminated, there are these things that bring them a new status of privilege, which makes them harder to be tolerated in the eyes of others. And things keep spinning in this circle of discrimination and toleration, in fashion, as it does in society. Which does nothing but to prove, once again, how fashion, no matter how beautiful and open-minded it may be, is a reflection of society, along with its ugliest flaws.
- Ioana Ulmeanu"
Source : ELLE Romania, May 2011. "Discriminating Fashion : About color, size, disabilities and gender".
Thursday, 31 January 2013
Wednesday, 30 January 2013
Elle Article, Part 3 : Disabilities
With and without disabilities
Weight and skin tone aren't the only drawbacks of today's model. Another thing that keeps him/her away from fashion editorials and catwalks is represented by disabilities. In a world where people with disabilities hardly find a place - any place - , fashion would seem the least important. However, as exceptions are everywhere, some designers did bring this issue to the table. And one of the pioneers was Alexander McQueen, the one who decided that athlete Aimee Mullins should feature in one of his fashion shows, in 1998. The story was simple : Mullins, who had both her legs amputated and who had already set athletic records, featured in i-D and declared, among others, that she would enjoy having a pair of beautiful legs. Photographer Nick Knight read the story and informed McQueen about it, who invited her to feature in one of his hows. The prostheses he made for me were magnificent, everybody thought they were actual boots,stated Mullins in 2003 for The Observer. It was astonishing to take part in such a beautiful show. But the next day Le Figaro wrote an article that quoted Pierre Bergé, who hadn't actually seen the presentation but who claimed that McQueen is a provocative voyeur and that his show exploited me. Associated Press took over the story and only focused on the controversy, and suddenly, people stopped saying different than the fact that I had been part of a scandal.
Things have evolved in this field too, even if we only consider the fact that Shannon Murray became the face of one of Debenhams' lines. Murray is 33 and, although she has been in a wheelchair since she was 14, she kept her dream of becoming a model. She wrote that her job is a first step and I only figure out the potential of the shoot when I got there - I realized it is a small step to inclusion and portrayal. I hope the images will change a few prejudice people have about disabilities.The same brand previously announced that it will use size 16 mannequins for a trial period in the shops. The only question that was raised in this case was whether Debenhams would keep taking this type of actions in the future or it is doing it for the sake of publicity. But the audience's feedback counts in such situations, because, even if pictures of people with disabilities may visually have a bigger impact, this doesn't guarantee the success of sales. And this success will be seen in the sales of A Men perfume launched by Thierry Mugler, whose new face is athlete Oscar Pistorius. The amputee sprinter features in the brand's campaigns, running and holding a bottle of perfume in his hand, while his prostheses are covered in chromium chassis designed by Thierry Mugler and Stefano Canulli.
But models with motor disabilities are not the only exception in fashion. Even models with non-visible disabilities suffer because of prejudice. Among them, hearing impaired Kellie Moody, who remembers winning Miss Deaf UK title in 2007 and being photographed by a famous photographer who didn't even return her calls when she had to claim her award. Moody then took part in Britain's Missing Top Model TV show, broadcasted on BBC Three, which did start a few controversies. Meanwhile, Kellie Moody, who claims that the only difference between her and a successful model is the fact that she can't hear, only got one advertising job for Siemens hearing aids, but she does wish to get a job for a fashion brand, be it Primark or Prada. Nevertheless, as long as public's feedback is negative, this thing won't happen. And the shocked letters sent by the audience to Cerrie Burnell, the telecaster of BBC's kids channel, who only has one arm (in which parents stated that her infirmity frightens the children) aren't the feedback one would expect.
Source : ELLE Romania, May 2011. "Discriminating Fashion : About color, size, disabilities and gender".
Weight and skin tone aren't the only drawbacks of today's model. Another thing that keeps him/her away from fashion editorials and catwalks is represented by disabilities. In a world where people with disabilities hardly find a place - any place - , fashion would seem the least important. However, as exceptions are everywhere, some designers did bring this issue to the table. And one of the pioneers was Alexander McQueen, the one who decided that athlete Aimee Mullins should feature in one of his fashion shows, in 1998. The story was simple : Mullins, who had both her legs amputated and who had already set athletic records, featured in i-D and declared, among others, that she would enjoy having a pair of beautiful legs. Photographer Nick Knight read the story and informed McQueen about it, who invited her to feature in one of his hows. The prostheses he made for me were magnificent, everybody thought they were actual boots,stated Mullins in 2003 for The Observer. It was astonishing to take part in such a beautiful show. But the next day Le Figaro wrote an article that quoted Pierre Bergé, who hadn't actually seen the presentation but who claimed that McQueen is a provocative voyeur and that his show exploited me. Associated Press took over the story and only focused on the controversy, and suddenly, people stopped saying different than the fact that I had been part of a scandal.
Things have evolved in this field too, even if we only consider the fact that Shannon Murray became the face of one of Debenhams' lines. Murray is 33 and, although she has been in a wheelchair since she was 14, she kept her dream of becoming a model. She wrote that her job is a first step and I only figure out the potential of the shoot when I got there - I realized it is a small step to inclusion and portrayal. I hope the images will change a few prejudice people have about disabilities.The same brand previously announced that it will use size 16 mannequins for a trial period in the shops. The only question that was raised in this case was whether Debenhams would keep taking this type of actions in the future or it is doing it for the sake of publicity. But the audience's feedback counts in such situations, because, even if pictures of people with disabilities may visually have a bigger impact, this doesn't guarantee the success of sales. And this success will be seen in the sales of A Men perfume launched by Thierry Mugler, whose new face is athlete Oscar Pistorius. The amputee sprinter features in the brand's campaigns, running and holding a bottle of perfume in his hand, while his prostheses are covered in chromium chassis designed by Thierry Mugler and Stefano Canulli.
But models with motor disabilities are not the only exception in fashion. Even models with non-visible disabilities suffer because of prejudice. Among them, hearing impaired Kellie Moody, who remembers winning Miss Deaf UK title in 2007 and being photographed by a famous photographer who didn't even return her calls when she had to claim her award. Moody then took part in Britain's Missing Top Model TV show, broadcasted on BBC Three, which did start a few controversies. Meanwhile, Kellie Moody, who claims that the only difference between her and a successful model is the fact that she can't hear, only got one advertising job for Siemens hearing aids, but she does wish to get a job for a fashion brand, be it Primark or Prada. Nevertheless, as long as public's feedback is negative, this thing won't happen. And the shocked letters sent by the audience to Cerrie Burnell, the telecaster of BBC's kids channel, who only has one arm (in which parents stated that her infirmity frightens the children) aren't the feedback one would expect.
Source : ELLE Romania, May 2011. "Discriminating Fashion : About color, size, disabilities and gender".
Tuesday, 29 January 2013
Interviewing the Customer
As a form of primary research, I've conducted an interview with my grandmother:). After telling her a few things about the All Walks philosophy, I've ask her about her opinion on beauty ideals these days and on how she relates to them, as a customer.
As I was expecting, she was glad to hear that someone is trying to do something about the lack of diversity in the world of fashion, especially when it comes to size and age. She was also glad that I, as a young fashion student, have been given such a brief. What I noticed is that she didn't seem to be bothered by photographic promotional campaigns inside stores. She considers that it is perfectly fine for these to picture thin, young models, as long as you can find the clothing items that they promote in larger sizes inside the store. However, regarding catwalk shows, she does find the featuring models to be outrageously skinny. "Skin and bones", like she always says. I have also asked her about the way fashion magazines were back in the days. And, although she disapproved of the printing and paper quality, she did like find the content to be more fashion focused, rather than model focused, as it tends to be now. After all, it is supposed to be a fashion magazine, not a model catalogue. One last thing that she said, when I asked her about skinny models with no curves at all, is that it is their lack of curves that make designers choose to work them, because it actually points out their young age.
As I was expecting, she was glad to hear that someone is trying to do something about the lack of diversity in the world of fashion, especially when it comes to size and age. She was also glad that I, as a young fashion student, have been given such a brief. What I noticed is that she didn't seem to be bothered by photographic promotional campaigns inside stores. She considers that it is perfectly fine for these to picture thin, young models, as long as you can find the clothing items that they promote in larger sizes inside the store. However, regarding catwalk shows, she does find the featuring models to be outrageously skinny. "Skin and bones", like she always says. I have also asked her about the way fashion magazines were back in the days. And, although she disapproved of the printing and paper quality, she did like find the content to be more fashion focused, rather than model focused, as it tends to be now. After all, it is supposed to be a fashion magazine, not a model catalogue. One last thing that she said, when I asked her about skinny models with no curves at all, is that it is their lack of curves that make designers choose to work them, because it actually points out their young age.
Elle Article, Part 2 : Size
Size Zero
Besides racism, size is another issue in the fashion industry; because its main statement is that clothes look better on skinny people. The problem is that fashion buyers' sizes do not match the catwalk models' at all. Probably the most famous name of a plus-size model that fights for a more realistic size for runway models is Crystal Renn. Author of "Hungry" book, Renn has been talking both in her novel, and in many interviews about the health issues she had been going through while trying to attain the much-desirable size 0 and about the way she managed to become size 12 successful model. Moreover, she became a militant for the rights of over-sized women, reporting general discrimination against them. But Renn is, in her own way, privileged, and her plus-sized model status has brought her a few advantages such as editorials in Vogue, ELLE, i-D, Vanity Fair or Harper's Bazaar, and advertising contracts with H&M, Chanel, Jimmy Choo, Jean Paul Gaultier, Dsquared, as well as catwalks for Vena Cava, Jean Paul Gaultier or Chanel.
Her jubilant story about anorexia and the pressures in the world of fashion has changed some people's mentalities, and probably the best example is the German magazine, Brigitte, that promised never to use skinny models in its issues again. So, Renn's history is a successful story and her plus-sized model career bears witness to it, but the pressures she had to undergo until she accepted her body were huge. When I was 14, a model scout told me I could become a supermodel just like Gisele, but only if I lost 40% of my weight. So I decided to do it. I used to ask how many calories does chewing gum have and I spend 8 hours at the gym every day. My hair started falling and I became more and more isolated, said Felix Rettberg's model for Spiegel. Now, Renn is fighing to make designers change the standard sizes for their clothes and to make UK size 10 become the gauge for catwalk models. Models should be beautiful women who inspire poeple. They shouldn't starve themselves in order to be accepted. It would be impossible to go below today's standards. If they were any thinner, they would be dead.
After a while, the plus-size models issue was being discussed even more, along with Lizzie Miller's untouched, barely nude photograph in Glamour magazine. In September 2009, the editors' bold decision has brought them many congratulations and many debates as well. Kate Dillon, the first plus-size model to be in Vogue magazine (2000) stated that Miller's feature in Glamour shouldn't have surprised anyone, and Emme, considered a plus-size supermodel, shared some details on hidden clothing lines that renown brands such as Michael Kors or Calvin Klein were dedicating to overweight women. This was happening considering that over 40% of the women in America were size 14+, while only 10% of the retailers were selling clothes for them. Therefore, it seems that the industry's decision to promote and maintain an unrealistic beauty ideal is not very efficient, because many of the buyers simply can't fit in designer clothes. And in times of crisis, high-end fashion cannot afford not to win clientele.
However, opinions stay ambivalent. For example, Anna Wintour was declaring more than a year ago, at a fashion healthcare forum held by Harvard University, that each and every one of us needs to realize we are all responsible for models’ health. We must reverse the tyranny of sample clothes that just barely fit a 13-year-old on the edge of puberty, but Vogue US didn't feature many overweight women. And Karl Lagerfeld, event though he had chosen Crystal Renn for Chanel shows,has startled people with declarations such as the one that he gave on a Radio 4 channel : In France, less tha 1% of the population is anorexic, while 30% of the youth is overweight. So we should worry about the millions of fat people before talking about the rest.
And not even Isabelle Caro's tragedy, the model who passed away in November 2012 because of anorexia and whose images, wearing the signature of the famous Oliviero Toscani, have terrified people in the No Anorexia campaign, didn't change much.
Source : ELLE Romania, May 2011. "Discriminating Fashion : About color, size, disabilities and gender".
Besides racism, size is another issue in the fashion industry; because its main statement is that clothes look better on skinny people. The problem is that fashion buyers' sizes do not match the catwalk models' at all. Probably the most famous name of a plus-size model that fights for a more realistic size for runway models is Crystal Renn. Author of "Hungry" book, Renn has been talking both in her novel, and in many interviews about the health issues she had been going through while trying to attain the much-desirable size 0 and about the way she managed to become size 12 successful model. Moreover, she became a militant for the rights of over-sized women, reporting general discrimination against them. But Renn is, in her own way, privileged, and her plus-sized model status has brought her a few advantages such as editorials in Vogue, ELLE, i-D, Vanity Fair or Harper's Bazaar, and advertising contracts with H&M, Chanel, Jimmy Choo, Jean Paul Gaultier, Dsquared, as well as catwalks for Vena Cava, Jean Paul Gaultier or Chanel.
Her jubilant story about anorexia and the pressures in the world of fashion has changed some people's mentalities, and probably the best example is the German magazine, Brigitte, that promised never to use skinny models in its issues again. So, Renn's history is a successful story and her plus-sized model career bears witness to it, but the pressures she had to undergo until she accepted her body were huge. When I was 14, a model scout told me I could become a supermodel just like Gisele, but only if I lost 40% of my weight. So I decided to do it. I used to ask how many calories does chewing gum have and I spend 8 hours at the gym every day. My hair started falling and I became more and more isolated, said Felix Rettberg's model for Spiegel. Now, Renn is fighing to make designers change the standard sizes for their clothes and to make UK size 10 become the gauge for catwalk models. Models should be beautiful women who inspire poeple. They shouldn't starve themselves in order to be accepted. It would be impossible to go below today's standards. If they were any thinner, they would be dead.
After a while, the plus-size models issue was being discussed even more, along with Lizzie Miller's untouched, barely nude photograph in Glamour magazine. In September 2009, the editors' bold decision has brought them many congratulations and many debates as well. Kate Dillon, the first plus-size model to be in Vogue magazine (2000) stated that Miller's feature in Glamour shouldn't have surprised anyone, and Emme, considered a plus-size supermodel, shared some details on hidden clothing lines that renown brands such as Michael Kors or Calvin Klein were dedicating to overweight women. This was happening considering that over 40% of the women in America were size 14+, while only 10% of the retailers were selling clothes for them. Therefore, it seems that the industry's decision to promote and maintain an unrealistic beauty ideal is not very efficient, because many of the buyers simply can't fit in designer clothes. And in times of crisis, high-end fashion cannot afford not to win clientele.
However, opinions stay ambivalent. For example, Anna Wintour was declaring more than a year ago, at a fashion healthcare forum held by Harvard University, that each and every one of us needs to realize we are all responsible for models’ health. We must reverse the tyranny of sample clothes that just barely fit a 13-year-old on the edge of puberty, but Vogue US didn't feature many overweight women. And Karl Lagerfeld, event though he had chosen Crystal Renn for Chanel shows,has startled people with declarations such as the one that he gave on a Radio 4 channel : In France, less tha 1% of the population is anorexic, while 30% of the youth is overweight. So we should worry about the millions of fat people before talking about the rest.
And not even Isabelle Caro's tragedy, the model who passed away in November 2012 because of anorexia and whose images, wearing the signature of the famous Oliviero Toscani, have terrified people in the No Anorexia campaign, didn't change much.
Source : ELLE Romania, May 2011. "Discriminating Fashion : About color, size, disabilities and gender".
Monday, 28 January 2013
Elle Article, Part 1 : Skin Tone
"As the history of fashion reflects the evolution of society in rather unflattering tones, it was only natural for it to have, regarding discrimination, as winding and steep a course as people's mentalities. Even though it is a creative field that has often abolished or, at least, replaced common rules, fashion has unfortunately kept the same guidelines for some of our features, which are considered politically incorrect and unworthy of being taken into consideration.
Colors of Beauty
Probably the most disputed aspect of beauty ideals seen in fashion magazines or on the catwalk has been the color of one's skin. Hence, for example, the fact that the first issue of Vogue that would have an Afro-American model on the cover came out in 1974, even though the magazine was launched in 1892. The name of that model is Beverly Johnson, a swimmer aspiring to become a lawyer at that time, who managed to become a successful model, first posing for Glamour magazine (in 1968) and then for Vogue. However, her remarkable career hasn't been obstacle-free because, for example, there were no styling products for black models at that time. The same thing was happening to Iman, the first black supermodel, who declared that when she first came to the USA, the general idea of beauty was the blonde, blue-eyed, white woman. One of her first jobs as a model was for Vogue as well, when she was only 18. At that time, the make-up artist asked her if she brought her own foundation. Her brands, Iman Cosmetics, launched in 1994, addresses all women, no matter the skin tone.
With very few exceptions, black models are still rarely seen in fashion magazines. That is why they have organized protests whenever they could. For example, in 2007, Naomi Campbell, Iman and Lyia Kebede along with Tyson Beckford have launched a campaign against racial discrimination and began by sharing some very interesting stories about the beginning of their careers. Naomi Campbell, e.g., mentioned that YSL threatened to stop his collaborations with Vogue Paris, unless they published a photograph of her on the cover, for racial reasons. And at that time, Claude Grunitzky, editor of Trace magazine, declared to The Guardian that, when the publication invited Iman to edit one of its issues, one of the major advertising clients has dropped out, apparently offended by the issue's slogan : Black girls rule. Iman said that it was hard for her to convince other black models to pose for the cover of that issue : I know how they felt about it, I myself wasn't comfortable being labeled as black at the beginning of my career, but now I celebrate this thing and I can see the difference.
But designer have always found ways to defend themselves when they were accused of being racist. Most of them emphasized on their creative decisions, based on the concepts of their collections : if a black model does not fit the concept and the line of the collection, then that model cannot present that collection on the catwalk. Naomi Campbell declared in a Metro interview that there was a time when she thought that things were about to change, but they didn't : Today, designers use, on average, between 1 to 3 colored models, and the agencies only represent a few black, latin or asian models, as well.
This is what the fashion industry looked like when Franca Sozzani, chief-editor of Italian Vogue edition, decided it was time to publish an all-black issue. The issue (July 2008) was sold out in UK and USA in only 72 hours, therefore, 60 thousand more copies were published.
Robin Givhan, the African-American editor of Washington Post and winner of the Pulitzer award for critics in 2006, has been very preoccupied with the phenomenon. At the end of last year, she was writing about Franca's decision to celebrate diversity in all of its forms. Even if Vogue Italia isn't as published as other issues of Vogue magazine, it has the reputation of being dedicated to insiders, capable of starting trends that would easily spread throughout the fashion publications market. Which is why Sozzani's initiatives such as the all-black issue, the Black Barbie issue and Vogue Black or Vogue Curvy websites are so important.
Sozzani's actions put questions of public and private identity, which were backed up by other Vogue editions. Anna Wintour from Vogue US admitted that, even though there are some black models in the pages of the magazine, these do not proportionally reflect the real number of black women the magazine addresses. Seeing representatives such as Halle Berry or Michelle Obama on the cover of Vogue US is still rare, and only happens due to their celebrity status. If Franca Sozzani's effort has another merit aside from her powerful statement, it is that she has shown the existence of an ignored market that needs to be taken into account.
It is that market segment that was bewildered, e.g., by the group of 5 African-American models that ended Alber Elbaz's show for Lanvin. After a series of Caucasian women wearing collection clothing, 5 other black models walked down the runway wearing a sort of capsule-collection, consisting of large tropical-patterned dresses. Even though Elbaz justified his decision as being fully based on aesthetic reasons, it became an important topic. I have been guided by Geoffrey Beene and YSL, who both worked with African-American girls. Not because it was a political statement, but because they were beautiful girls, said the designer. However, André Leon Talley, Vogue editor, said that bring together a group based on the skin tone in a political statement. Which is why such an incident questions the opening towards diversity of an industry that tries to promote itself as being more open-minded than others. Same for the fashion editorial published by Vogue Paris in 2009, picturing Lara Stone with her skin painted brown, Viktor & Rolf show featuring painted models, or the decision of Essence magazine, addressed to black women, to name their fashion editor a white person. The cover of Vogue US, presenting Gisele Bundchen next to Lebron James, has been compared (with some exaggerations) to the King Kong movie poster, which shows the biases and squeamishness of the public, as well as the industry undertaking an interpretable opening. Because, as the legendary black model Bethann Hardison used to say, in the world of fashion no one aims to be rasist, but the results of their work is rasist.
Source : ELLE Romania, May 2011. "Discriminating Fashion : About color, size, disabilities and gender".
Sunday, 27 January 2013
Bodies, by Susie Orbach
At the lecture Caryn Franklin held, she recommended that we read a book called Bodies, written by Susie Orbach. Unfortunately, I didn't find the book at the Library, but I read a review to get a glimpse on what it is about, on its theories. Here it is:
"In her first book, Fat Is a Feminist Issue, published 31 years ago, Susie Orbach told us why lots of women had a dysfunctional relationship with their bodies. Some women got fat, she said, not because they were greedy, but because being fat made them feel safe. For a woman, she said, being slim might get you the wrong kind of attention - not just from men, but from other women, too. So lots of people have an unconscious drive towards being fat, even if they think, on the surface, that they want to be slim. What an insight! That's what I thought, when I read it. And also: what a twisted world we live in!
As a psychotherapist, Orbach had asked women what their fat was actually doing for them. It was giving them a certain relief, they said. It "took them out of the category of woman and put them in the androgynous state of 'big girl'". It gave them something concrete to worry about, so they wouldn't have to think about all their other troubles. "Above all," Orbach wrote, "the fat woman wants to hide."
In this new book, Orbach tells us what has happened to our bodies in the intervening three decades. These days, we live in an even more twisted world. Or, as Orbach puts it, "the problems I sought to describe have mushroomed". Now that we no longer use our bodies to make things, she says, we make our bodies instead. Our bodies are the product. Of course, the human body has always been sculpted by what it does. And now, mostly, it does not till the fields, or mine the coal, or hump things around. In the modern age - what Orbach calls "late modernity" - it sits at a keyboard, tapping away, like I'm doing right now - or on a sofa, reading a newspaper, like you're doing right now.
And what do sedentary people in modern societies have in common? What are we doing, exactly, when we sit at our keyboards? Well, for one thing, we're not getting much exercise. Weirdly, though, the less exercise we get, the more we worship the toned, impossible body of our dreams. But the body we dream of is always out of reach and getting harder to achieve with every passing year - for women, this body is slender body, with a certain type of breasts - and, lately, a certain type of bottom, too. For men, it's the six-pack, among other things.
So what's driving all of this? Why, Orbach asks, "is bodily contentment so hard to find"? In her first book, she showed us how people's bodies can be shaped by forces beyond their control. Here, she turns her attention to the controlling forces - "the merchants of body hatred". Her point is that capitalism works much better if we hate our bodies. If we're anxious and needy, we are better consumers; if we're anxious and needy when it comes to something as fundamental as our bodies, we are putty in the hands of marketeers and diet-merchants. And if we ever start to get comfortable with what we've got, along comes another body - another piece of unattainable perfection - to keep us anxious.
Who are these merchants of hatred? Where are all these images of perfection? Actually, they're everywhere. They are, I began to think as I read this, the people sitting at the keyboards, writing the ads and marketing the holidays, airbrushing the pictures and arranging the loans. They are us, me and you, communicating, right now, via a medium partly funded by advertising. And look at the ads! Look at the bodies in the ads! And think of the meaning of those bodies, and how they got there, and what those bodies will do to us. That's one of the things I was thinking, as I was reading this book. I was thinking: it's us - it's all of us! We are the merchants of body hatred.
Orbach takes us on a world tour of body anxiety - the rock videos, the magazine covers, the ads, the people who tweak the portraits of children to make them look perfect, the high heels made for babies to wear, the mothers who diet during pregnancy, the elective caesareans, the pressure to lose "baby weight" in new mothers, the spread of cosmetic surgery, the spread of cosmetic surgery shows... and it's all repeating the same mantra about the need, particularly for women, to be slim and sexy, but with the right breasts and now the right bottom. "Visual muzak" she calls it.
She's right, just like she was right 31 years ago. Our bodies are being shaped by forces beyond our control and these forces are malign. She's right about cosmetic surgery - it's becoming more and more normalised and this just raises the bar, so that what looks beautiful today will look less beautiful tomorrow. She's right about the cult of celebrities."By creating internationally recognisable iconic figures, it appears to be inclusive and democratic," she says. But it's not. It "sucks out variety". It makes us all want to look like the same few people.
And she's right about the diet industry. Did you know that, in America, the diet industry is worth $100bn a year? And the annual education budget is $127bn? And diets mostly don't work. That's because, when you go on a diet, your body gets better at sucking calories out of the food that you do eat. So when you start to eat normally again, you balloon. And that's the whole point. That's where the $100bn comes from. Diets create a need for more diets. Or, as Orbach puts it: "Diet companies rely on a 95 per cent recidivism rate, a figure that should be etched into every dieter's consciousness."
But there was another voice in my head as I was reading this book about bodies. I was thinking six-packs, of clear, wrinkle-free skin, of better teeth and hair... and I secretly wanted these things. I was thinking of Brad Pitt. I was thinking of Brad Pitt's stomach. I was wondering how I could get Brad Pitt's stomach. What would life be like then? I kept thinking: I know, Susie, body tyranny is terrible. It's morally wrong and spiritually destructive. It was bad in 1978 and it's been getting worse ever since. But just imagine, all the same, a world of perfect toned slimness, in which...
I had to keep saying: wake up! She's right! And this is a terrific, timely book. Body tyranny has been hurting us for decades. At bottom, I think, it's about making us want things. Reading this book made me think: our system makes us want things until we're so damaged that we can't go on, and it's showing on our skinny, obese, scarred, tattooed, pierced and hated bodies. And now it looks like the system is breaking down. Which might be good news for bodies."
William Leith
The Observer ,
http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2009/feb/01/bodies-review-susie-orbach
"In her first book, Fat Is a Feminist Issue, published 31 years ago, Susie Orbach told us why lots of women had a dysfunctional relationship with their bodies. Some women got fat, she said, not because they were greedy, but because being fat made them feel safe. For a woman, she said, being slim might get you the wrong kind of attention - not just from men, but from other women, too. So lots of people have an unconscious drive towards being fat, even if they think, on the surface, that they want to be slim. What an insight! That's what I thought, when I read it. And also: what a twisted world we live in!
As a psychotherapist, Orbach had asked women what their fat was actually doing for them. It was giving them a certain relief, they said. It "took them out of the category of woman and put them in the androgynous state of 'big girl'". It gave them something concrete to worry about, so they wouldn't have to think about all their other troubles. "Above all," Orbach wrote, "the fat woman wants to hide."
In this new book, Orbach tells us what has happened to our bodies in the intervening three decades. These days, we live in an even more twisted world. Or, as Orbach puts it, "the problems I sought to describe have mushroomed". Now that we no longer use our bodies to make things, she says, we make our bodies instead. Our bodies are the product. Of course, the human body has always been sculpted by what it does. And now, mostly, it does not till the fields, or mine the coal, or hump things around. In the modern age - what Orbach calls "late modernity" - it sits at a keyboard, tapping away, like I'm doing right now - or on a sofa, reading a newspaper, like you're doing right now.
And what do sedentary people in modern societies have in common? What are we doing, exactly, when we sit at our keyboards? Well, for one thing, we're not getting much exercise. Weirdly, though, the less exercise we get, the more we worship the toned, impossible body of our dreams. But the body we dream of is always out of reach and getting harder to achieve with every passing year - for women, this body is slender body, with a certain type of breasts - and, lately, a certain type of bottom, too. For men, it's the six-pack, among other things.
So what's driving all of this? Why, Orbach asks, "is bodily contentment so hard to find"? In her first book, she showed us how people's bodies can be shaped by forces beyond their control. Here, she turns her attention to the controlling forces - "the merchants of body hatred". Her point is that capitalism works much better if we hate our bodies. If we're anxious and needy, we are better consumers; if we're anxious and needy when it comes to something as fundamental as our bodies, we are putty in the hands of marketeers and diet-merchants. And if we ever start to get comfortable with what we've got, along comes another body - another piece of unattainable perfection - to keep us anxious.
Who are these merchants of hatred? Where are all these images of perfection? Actually, they're everywhere. They are, I began to think as I read this, the people sitting at the keyboards, writing the ads and marketing the holidays, airbrushing the pictures and arranging the loans. They are us, me and you, communicating, right now, via a medium partly funded by advertising. And look at the ads! Look at the bodies in the ads! And think of the meaning of those bodies, and how they got there, and what those bodies will do to us. That's one of the things I was thinking, as I was reading this book. I was thinking: it's us - it's all of us! We are the merchants of body hatred.
Orbach takes us on a world tour of body anxiety - the rock videos, the magazine covers, the ads, the people who tweak the portraits of children to make them look perfect, the high heels made for babies to wear, the mothers who diet during pregnancy, the elective caesareans, the pressure to lose "baby weight" in new mothers, the spread of cosmetic surgery, the spread of cosmetic surgery shows... and it's all repeating the same mantra about the need, particularly for women, to be slim and sexy, but with the right breasts and now the right bottom. "Visual muzak" she calls it.
She's right, just like she was right 31 years ago. Our bodies are being shaped by forces beyond our control and these forces are malign. She's right about cosmetic surgery - it's becoming more and more normalised and this just raises the bar, so that what looks beautiful today will look less beautiful tomorrow. She's right about the cult of celebrities."By creating internationally recognisable iconic figures, it appears to be inclusive and democratic," she says. But it's not. It "sucks out variety". It makes us all want to look like the same few people.
And she's right about the diet industry. Did you know that, in America, the diet industry is worth $100bn a year? And the annual education budget is $127bn? And diets mostly don't work. That's because, when you go on a diet, your body gets better at sucking calories out of the food that you do eat. So when you start to eat normally again, you balloon. And that's the whole point. That's where the $100bn comes from. Diets create a need for more diets. Or, as Orbach puts it: "Diet companies rely on a 95 per cent recidivism rate, a figure that should be etched into every dieter's consciousness."
But there was another voice in my head as I was reading this book about bodies. I was thinking six-packs, of clear, wrinkle-free skin, of better teeth and hair... and I secretly wanted these things. I was thinking of Brad Pitt. I was thinking of Brad Pitt's stomach. I was wondering how I could get Brad Pitt's stomach. What would life be like then? I kept thinking: I know, Susie, body tyranny is terrible. It's morally wrong and spiritually destructive. It was bad in 1978 and it's been getting worse ever since. But just imagine, all the same, a world of perfect toned slimness, in which...
I had to keep saying: wake up! She's right! And this is a terrific, timely book. Body tyranny has been hurting us for decades. At bottom, I think, it's about making us want things. Reading this book made me think: our system makes us want things until we're so damaged that we can't go on, and it's showing on our skinny, obese, scarred, tattooed, pierced and hated bodies. And now it looks like the system is breaking down. Which might be good news for bodies."
William Leith
The Observer ,
http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2009/feb/01/bodies-review-susie-orbach
Saturday, 26 January 2013
Chosen Theme & Mood Board
I've decided to focus on models with disabilities in this project. Hopefully, I will find a woman with an actual disability, but if I won't manage to do that, I might as well try to get hold of a wheelchair and then find a model. This is probably a better thing to do because I think that the key to a successful shoot is a gorgeous model and it would be far more easy to find the perfect model. However, I am a bit discouraged by the fact that Caryn didn't mention anything about disabilities in Wednesday's lecture. But if you read i-D's online article on Diversity NOW!, it does cover this subject. Here is the paragraph:
Alexander McQueen called Paralympian and double amputee Aimee Mullins his muse, and one of Nick Knight’s most famous shoots was using models with “disabilities”, saying “…my aim was to push back the boundaries of what is and isn’t beautiful”. After all, style is about being different isn’t it? Standing out not blending in. That’s the irony, the people who run the fashion business all look different and have different interests and hair and some have really weird dress sense but that’s why everyone adores them, because they’re characters, individuals, and that’s why they’ve made it. But for some reason, the people they choose to represent them in fashion imagery are often of the size 6, 5’10″ breed and not representative of any of the above. i-D Founder and Editor in Chief Terry Jones comments: “All Walks is relevant today because it brings back the importance of personal i-Dentity.” That’s what i-D is about, that’s what All Walks is about, now tell us what you’re about.
Currently, I'm thinking of taking some B&W shots of a model in a wheelchair. Her pose and her facial expression should evoke confidence, power, sensuality. I've created a mood board to try and show what I have in mind.
Alexander McQueen called Paralympian and double amputee Aimee Mullins his muse, and one of Nick Knight’s most famous shoots was using models with “disabilities”, saying “…my aim was to push back the boundaries of what is and isn’t beautiful”. After all, style is about being different isn’t it? Standing out not blending in. That’s the irony, the people who run the fashion business all look different and have different interests and hair and some have really weird dress sense but that’s why everyone adores them, because they’re characters, individuals, and that’s why they’ve made it. But for some reason, the people they choose to represent them in fashion imagery are often of the size 6, 5’10″ breed and not representative of any of the above. i-D Founder and Editor in Chief Terry Jones comments: “All Walks is relevant today because it brings back the importance of personal i-Dentity.” That’s what i-D is about, that’s what All Walks is about, now tell us what you’re about.
Currently, I'm thinking of taking some B&W shots of a model in a wheelchair. Her pose and her facial expression should evoke confidence, power, sensuality. I've created a mood board to try and show what I have in mind.
Every Body Counts!
In this case, it would probably sound like you are a self-destructive hopeless addict. Should this impress me? Make me want to buy the product, respect the brand? And the models, because they are the main topic here, are far from desirable, in my opinion. What is beautiful about the beaten, tortured, near to death "beauty ideal" in this picture?
Caryn then started talking a bit about the so-called fashion porn. OK, sex sells, we get that. But I think too many designers fail to see the boundaries between successful ads and uncomfortable/disturbing ones. The imagery we grow up on influences, in one way or another, our vision on life. It especially influences the youth, who isn't always capable of telling right from wrong. And I think that there are many more teens and children who read Elle, Vogue, Harper's Bazaar than women for whom these magazines are actually designed.
![]() |
| Founders of All Walks Catwalk: Debra Bourne, Erin O'Connor, Caryn Franklin |
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)








