"As the history of fashion reflects the evolution of society in rather unflattering tones, it was only natural for it to have, regarding discrimination, as winding and steep a course as people's mentalities. Even though it is a creative field that has often abolished or, at least, replaced common rules, fashion has unfortunately kept the same guidelines for some of our features, which are considered politically incorrect and unworthy of being taken into consideration.
Colors of Beauty
Probably the most disputed aspect of beauty ideals seen in fashion magazines or on the catwalk has been the color of one's skin. Hence, for example, the fact that the first issue of Vogue that would have an Afro-American model on the cover came out in 1974, even though the magazine was launched in 1892. The name of that model is Beverly Johnson, a swimmer aspiring to become a lawyer at that time, who managed to become a successful model, first posing for Glamour magazine (in 1968) and then for Vogue. However, her remarkable career hasn't been obstacle-free because, for example, there were no styling products for black models at that time. The same thing was happening to Iman, the first black supermodel, who declared that when she first came to the USA, the general idea of beauty was the blonde, blue-eyed, white woman. One of her first jobs as a model was for Vogue as well, when she was only 18. At that time, the make-up artist asked her if she brought her own foundation. Her brands, Iman Cosmetics, launched in 1994, addresses all women, no matter the skin tone.
With very few exceptions, black models are still rarely seen in fashion magazines. That is why they have organized protests whenever they could. For example, in 2007, Naomi Campbell, Iman and Lyia Kebede along with Tyson Beckford have launched a campaign against racial discrimination and began by sharing some very interesting stories about the beginning of their careers. Naomi Campbell, e.g., mentioned that YSL threatened to stop his collaborations with Vogue Paris, unless they published a photograph of her on the cover, for racial reasons. And at that time, Claude Grunitzky, editor of Trace magazine, declared to The Guardian that, when the publication invited Iman to edit one of its issues, one of the major advertising clients has dropped out, apparently offended by the issue's slogan : Black girls rule. Iman said that it was hard for her to convince other black models to pose for the cover of that issue : I know how they felt about it, I myself wasn't comfortable being labeled as black at the beginning of my career, but now I celebrate this thing and I can see the difference.
But designer have always found ways to defend themselves when they were accused of being racist. Most of them emphasized on their creative decisions, based on the concepts of their collections : if a black model does not fit the concept and the line of the collection, then that model cannot present that collection on the catwalk. Naomi Campbell declared in a Metro interview that there was a time when she thought that things were about to change, but they didn't : Today, designers use, on average, between 1 to 3 colored models, and the agencies only represent a few black, latin or asian models, as well.
This is what the fashion industry looked like when Franca Sozzani, chief-editor of Italian Vogue edition, decided it was time to publish an all-black issue. The issue (July 2008) was sold out in UK and USA in only 72 hours, therefore, 60 thousand more copies were published.
Robin Givhan, the African-American editor of Washington Post and winner of the Pulitzer award for critics in 2006, has been very preoccupied with the phenomenon. At the end of last year, she was writing about Franca's decision to celebrate diversity in all of its forms. Even if Vogue Italia isn't as published as other issues of Vogue magazine, it has the reputation of being dedicated to insiders, capable of starting trends that would easily spread throughout the fashion publications market. Which is why Sozzani's initiatives such as the all-black issue, the Black Barbie issue and Vogue Black or Vogue Curvy websites are so important.
Sozzani's actions put questions of public and private identity, which were backed up by other Vogue editions. Anna Wintour from Vogue US admitted that, even though there are some black models in the pages of the magazine, these do not proportionally reflect the real number of black women the magazine addresses. Seeing representatives such as Halle Berry or Michelle Obama on the cover of Vogue US is still rare, and only happens due to their celebrity status. If Franca Sozzani's effort has another merit aside from her powerful statement, it is that she has shown the existence of an ignored market that needs to be taken into account.
It is that market segment that was bewildered, e.g., by the group of 5 African-American models that ended Alber Elbaz's show for Lanvin. After a series of Caucasian women wearing collection clothing, 5 other black models walked down the runway wearing a sort of capsule-collection, consisting of large tropical-patterned dresses. Even though Elbaz justified his decision as being fully based on aesthetic reasons, it became an important topic. I have been guided by Geoffrey Beene and YSL, who both worked with African-American girls. Not because it was a political statement, but because they were beautiful girls, said the designer. However, André Leon Talley, Vogue editor, said that bring together a group based on the skin tone in a political statement. Which is why such an incident questions the opening towards diversity of an industry that tries to promote itself as being more open-minded than others. Same for the fashion editorial published by Vogue Paris in 2009, picturing Lara Stone with her skin painted brown, Viktor & Rolf show featuring painted models, or the decision of Essence magazine, addressed to black women, to name their fashion editor a white person. The cover of Vogue US, presenting Gisele Bundchen next to Lebron James, has been compared (with some exaggerations) to the King Kong movie poster, which shows the biases and squeamishness of the public, as well as the industry undertaking an interpretable opening. Because, as the legendary black model Bethann Hardison used to say, in the world of fashion no one aims to be rasist, but the results of their work is rasist.
Source : ELLE Romania, May 2011. "Discriminating Fashion : About color, size, disabilities and gender".

No comments:
Post a Comment