Thursday, 31 January 2013

Elle Article, Part 4 : Gender

The tolerated gender

Finally, this leaves us to gender discrimination, which is, at least lately, more of a positive one. If, many years ago, transgender model April Ashley ( the first person in UK to have a sex-change operation) was being photographed by David Bailey for Vogue, but, at the same time, witnessing her film and fashion career fall apart because of the disclosure of her sexual identity (Sunday People, 1961), things have now changed.
 Andrej Pejic has already become a name in the fashion industry, partly due to his extraordinary physical features, but also because of the ambiguity that surrounds his sexual identity. Designers, headed by Jean Paul Gaultier, have decided to use him in women's fashion shows, and magazines such as Vogue Paris or Vogue Italia have promoted him in their pages, in photographs taken by Mert & Marcus or Steven Meisel. Moreover, Pejic is one of the faces of Marc by Marc Jacobs and has declared that he finds the idea of presenting both menswear and womenswear wonderful, even though he prefers women's glam clothes. The model, who has started experimenting on his look at the age of 14, is highly appreciated by designers, and Clare Coulson from Harper's Bazaar claims that this is only due to his beauty : Andrej is the perfect coat-hanger. And clothes always look better on a taller, thinner person. Harriet Quick from Vogue states that Andrej also reflects the present times and our culture. He makes people open their eyes and ask themselves questions on how one presents his own image.
 The same thing is happening with transgender model Leat T, face of Givenchy and of the latest covers of Love magazine. Lea has been the muse of designer Riccardo Tisci since she was 17 and has been working with him as a sample model, and when last year he decided to include her in the campaign of the brand he used to design for, a part of the contract stipulated that the model will be able to speak freely about his transgender status. Soon after the photographs came out, Lea T was talking in an interview for New York Times about the fact that, being trans-sexual, she cannot imagine having a bright future. It's a little message, the fact that transgenders can do the same things that boys and girls do. Maybe a trans-sexual will set up a magazine and believe that he/she can be whatever he/she wants to be. This is why I did the Givenchy campaign. However, Katie Grand, chief-editor of Love magazine, spoke differently in last issue's editorial about the decision to feature Lea on the cover :  We were more preoccupied by fashion than we were by biology when we decided to do this issue. Some of the models are transgender, but we included them because they are beautiful. What people do with what's inside their pants can be interesting, but less interesting, we believe, than the way they wear the pants. It's about fashion, not bodies, and as Lionel Vermeil noticed, clothes don't have a gender. Lea T, however, has actually been talking about sexes in the interview she gave to Isaac Lock : Everything is scandalous when you are trans-sexual. If a trans-sexual poses nude, it's a scandal. If he/she gets a job, it's a scandal. It's difficult to find opportunities. I wasn;t born a woman, so I can wish to be a woman. You have to be true to yourself about some things. If God came to ma and asked me what I wanted to be, I would say a woman. But I'm not a woman. I'm a trans-sexual. You have to be proud of this. If you aren't telling this to people, you are, in fact, saying that there is something wrong with it. And Riccardo Tisci mentioned in the pages of the same magazine that his choice of featuring Lea T in that issue is far from being heroic. This is not the free world that we picture. I tested this 4 years ago, when I opened a show with 8 black girls. I made Lea catwalk in a show many years ago, and people were looking at her as if she came from a different planet. Of course, some of the feedback was positive and that;s great, but many people still aren't OK with this, and I'm surprised - also because transgenders like beauty, fashion as well. Of course, some of them have money because they prostitute, but they are people who buy Givenchy, Louis Vuitton, Dolce&Gabbana or Chanel. Why should we hide from this? Tisci's act, however, says a lot of things, and not all of them are good,no matter how worthwhile his intentions may be. The same goes with Marc Jacobs' travesty on the cover of Industrie magazine, or James Franco's in Candy.

As long as window display mannequins are starting to lack faces, Afro-American or Asian ones, or over-sized ones don't sell and aren't used, we are still talking discrimination. The same goes when brands such as American Apparel, Abercrombie & Fitch or even Prada choose their employees based on their looks. Rina Bovrisse's trial, ex-employee of Prada in Japan, who has been fired and harassed because she wasn't following the Prada Look, has brought together more employees of the company who had filed similar complaints, and this does not help the brand's image. Moreover, she claims that fashion discriminates, still. And it's not just the negative discrimination, but the positive, too. Because, as we know, the latter comes from an excess, from fixing a mistake. And the success of a Lea T is partly due to the craving for any kind of publicity that makes clothes or magazines sell, but because of this type of tolerance, as well, which, most often, only does good to the prides of those who tolerate. It's not a virtue to tolerate, because this is what gives you the impression that you are superior and, therefore, in a condition to tolerate. Likewise, to those tolerated or positively discriminated, there are these things that bring them a new status of privilege, which makes them harder to be tolerated in the eyes of others. And things keep spinning in this circle of discrimination and toleration, in fashion, as it does in society. Which does nothing but to prove, once again, how fashion, no matter how beautiful and open-minded it may be, is a reflection of society, along with its ugliest flaws.

- Ioana Ulmeanu"


Source :  ELLE Romania, May 2011. "Discriminating Fashion : About color, size, disabilities and gender".


No comments:

Post a Comment